5 North Fleming Court, Montauk, NY 11954

Montauk Hillside Retreat with Pool and Possibilities

Elegantly renovated and set on a lush 0.71-acre hillside parcel bordering preserved land, this three-bedroom, three-and-a-half-bath residence offers privacy, scale, and a strong connection to its natural surroundings, with the possibility for a pool house. Tucked away on a cul-de-sac with no through traffic, the property offers a sense of quiet and seclusion. The main level unfolds from a central entry into two distinct, light-filled living areas, with a beautifully designed kitchen opening to the dining area and living area, and a separate living/media room-featuring an oversized projection wall set above a wood-burning fireplace-providing a more private retreat. An oversized deck spans the full width of the home with access from either side, creating a seamless indoor-outdoor flow for dining and lounging. Set into the hillside, the pool and hot tub occupy a lower level, maintaining both separation and visual connection, with an outdoor shower completing the setting. The upper level features an en-suite primary bedroom, along with two additional guest rooms and a full hall bath, while the lower level offers additional space with a range of possibilities, all within close proximity to Montauk's beaches, dining, and village amenities.