5 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

$1,999,999 Sold Price

Sold on 6/18/2026

3 Beds

3 Baths

2000 SF

Built In 2023

Listing ID	906567



Property Type	House



County	Suffolk



Township	Shelter Island Heights

Hamlet	Shelter Island Heights



Tax ID	0700-005.000-0005-020.001



FEMA Flood Map	fema.gov/portal



Year Built	2023

Associated Documents

FLOORPLAN

5 Grand Avenue Elevations

Virtual Tour

Wonderful in Town Residence

Introducing new construction in the Historic Business District of Shelter Island Heights. It is a true testament to modern luxury and timeless charm. Keeping in the tradition of homes located in the Heights district of Shelter Island, This farmhouse boasts three bedrooms and three bathrooms, Modern Scandinavian wood burning stove, and wide plank white oak hardware floors. Property Zoning is Business B which includes four parking spaces, and a two-car garage. The main house has 2,000 square footage with a custom loft. An 880 square footage basement with full height ceilings. The floors are 10" Wide Country White Oak hardwood flooring. The wrap-around covered porch has 625 square feet to enjoy your morning coffee or a glass of wine while entertaining. This is a one-of-a-kind property that comes on the market once in a lifetime. There is an abundance of natural light and high ceilings that make this property for what you want to design. Come see for yourself why this is the ideal property in Shelter Island Heights for all the right reasons, close to shops, restaurants, and the ferry. Make this your dream home where memories are made that will last a lifetime. You can have it all.

MORE ▼

Property Details

3 Total Bedrooms
3 Full Baths
2000 SF (AG)
2000 SF (Total)
0.25 Acres
Built in 2023
2 Stories
Farmhouse Style
Full Basement
Lower Level: Unfinished

Interior Features

Open Kitchen
Quartz Kitchen Counter
Oven/Range
Refrigerator
Dishwasher
Appliance Hot Water Heater
Hardwood Flooring
Den/Office
Primary Bedroom
en Suite Bathroom
Great Room
Kitchen
Laundry
Loft
Private Guestroom
First Floor Primary Bedroom
First Floor Bathroom
1 Fireplace
Wood Stove
Forced Air
2 Heat/AC Zones
Central A/C

Exterior Features

Frame Construction
Wood Siding
Detached Garage
2 Garage Spaces
Community Water
Community Septic
Deck
Open Porch
Covered Porch
New Construction
Near Bus
Near Train

Sale Information

Sold on 6/18/2026
Sold for $1,999,999

Previously Listed By

Peter M. McCracken

Corcoran Group (Shelter Island)

Mobile: 631-774-0107

Listing data is deemed reliable but is NOT guaranteed accurate.

Who Would You Like to Contact Today?

I want to contact an agent about this property!

I wish to provide feedback about the website functionality

Contact Agent

Your Name:
Email:
Phone:
Message:	I would like more information regarding the Corcoran Hamptons Listing #906567 at 5 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY.
Security:	What is 8 minus 2?